Custom Cakes in White Plains, Crafted for Every Occasion

At White Plains Bake Shoppe, every custom cake is baked from scratch and made to match your vision. From birthday and wedding cakes to school-themed celebration cakes, our team brings decades of experience to every order. If you're looking for custom cakes in White Plains, you've found the right place.

Black circle with a white percent sign icon

New Customer Offer

10% Off Discount

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit

(000) 000-0000

Made From Scratch, Made for You
Personalized Cakes Baked Fresh Every Day
Every cake we produce is baked on-site the same day it is picked up. We do not ship in frozen layers or use pre-made bases. From the batter to the finishing details, your personalized birthday cake or specialty event cake is built by hand in our White Plains kitchen. Our lead baker, Alissa Roldan, has been perfecting this craft since she was 10 years old, and that dedication shows in every tier, every frosting swirl, and every custom detail we add for you. This is what 35 years of experience actually looks like on a plate.
Designs for Every Milestone
From Weddings to Graduations, We Handle the Details
Our specialty cake orders cover the full range of life's big moments. Planning a wedding in Westchester County? We design wedding cakes in White Plains, NY that match your style and taste. Celebrating a college acceptance? Our College Acceptance Cookie Cakes feature your student's school colors and mascot, making them a one-of-a-kind way to mark the milestone. Birthdays, anniversaries, and any other occasion worth celebrating can be honored with a cake designed specifically for the person and the moment. We work with you directly to get every detail right, from flavor to finish.
Certified Kosher, Open to Everyone
A Higher Standard of Quality Baked Into Every Order
Our bakery operates within a certified Kosher environment, which means every custom cake we produce meets strict production standards. We offer Pareve and Dairy options, giving you full flexibility for events where dietary requirements matter. But our Kosher certification is not just for observant customers. It is a mark of cleaner ingredients and tighter quality control that benefits everyone who orders from us. As Westchester Magazine put it, do not miss our decadent flourless chocolate cake that will feed the whole family. That same commitment to quality goes into every custom design we create, no matter the occasion.
29 Years of Baking at This Address
A White Plains Institution Trusted for Custom Cake Design
White Plains Bake Shoppe has been a fixture on Mamaroneck Avenue for 29 years. The current owners, Alissa and Francis Roldan, stepped in as the new stewards of that legacy in November 2025, bringing fresh energy while keeping the scratch-made traditions completely intact. When you place a custom cake order with us, you are not just getting a beautiful dessert. You are working with a team that has deep roots in this community and a genuine commitment to getting your order right. Parking is available in the back, and we are open Wednesday through Sunday for consultations and pickup.
Your Questions, Answered
Common Questions About Our Custom Cake Orders

  • How far in advance do I need to place a custom cake order?

    For most custom cake orders, we recommend reaching out as early as possible to give our team enough time to plan your design, source any specific ingredients, and schedule production. Wedding cakes and larger specialty orders typically need the most lead time. For smaller personalized birthday cakes or specialty event cakes, a shorter window may be possible depending on our schedule. Contact us directly at our White Plains location to confirm availability and discuss your timeline.

  • Are your custom cakes available in Pareve or Dairy versions?

    Yes. Because we operate within a certified Kosher environment, we offer both Pareve and Dairy options for our custom cake orders. Pareve means the cake contains no dairy or meat products, which is important for many Kosher-observant customers and those with dairy sensitivities. When you place your order, let us know which version you need and we will make sure your cake is produced accordingly. This flexibility makes our specialty cake orders a good fit for a wide range of events and guests.

  • Can you make a cake with a specific school's colors and mascot for a graduation or college acceptance celebration?

    Absolutely. Our College Acceptance Cookie Cakes are one of our most popular specialty orders. We design them to feature your student's school colors and mascot, making them a genuinely personal way to celebrate the moment. They work well for parties, family gatherings, or any event where you want something beyond a standard cake. Just provide us with the school details when you place your order and we will take care of the rest.

  • Do you make wedding cakes, and do you serve areas outside of White Plains?

    Yes, we design and produce wedding cakes in White Plains, NY at our Mamaroneck Avenue location. We serve customers throughout Westchester County and the surrounding area. If you are planning a wedding in the region and want a scratch-made, certified Kosher wedding cake built to your specifications, reach out early to discuss your vision. Our team works with you directly on the design, flavor, and finish to make sure the final product matches what you have in mind.

  • Is everything in your custom cakes baked from scratch on-site?

    Yes, every cake we produce is baked fresh on-site at our White Plains bakery. We do not use frozen layers, pre-made bases, or commercially produced components. Our lead baker Alissa Roldan has been baking since she was 10 years old and brings over 35 years of hands-on experience to every order. That commitment to daily, scratch-made production is a core part of what we do, and it is what sets us apart from bakeries that rely on pre-packaged or shipped-in products.

  • What are your hours for picking up a custom cake order?

    During the summer season, we are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. Our hours are Wednesday through Friday from 8:00 AM to 5:30 PM, Saturday from 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM, and Sunday from 8:00 AM to 2:30 PM. We are located at 466 Mamaroneck Avenue in White Plains, and parking is available in the back of the building. If you have questions about pickup timing for a specific order, please contact us in advance so we can coordinate.

  • Does being a Kosher bakery mean only Kosher-observant customers can order custom cakes?

    Not at all. Our Kosher certification is open to everyone and is best understood as a quality standard. Operating within a certified Kosher environment means stricter ingredient sourcing and production oversight, which benefits every customer regardless of their dietary practice. As one reviewer put it, everything was absolutely delicious and it happened to have been Kosher. Our custom cakes are designed for anyone in Westchester County who wants a high-quality, scratch-made cake for their event.

REVIEWS

Real Reviews from Our Community